I mentioned Creative Memories as a BOLO back in 2015. And holy heck were those some high prices I got! I’m still fuzzy on what is going on with the company, but I think some of the products have been reissued and probably aren’t worth as much as they once were – but they’re still worth picking up at the right price.
At the beginning of March there is a huge church rummage sale that I look forward to going to every year. This year I spent a big chunk of the day there. It is one day only, opens at 8 a.m. and closes at 3 p.m. I was there in line ready to shop at 8 a.m. But starting at 1 p.m. everything goes half-price, so I went back later in the day.
And what did I find? A HUGE tote of brand new, sealed Creative Memories scrapbooking supplies.
What the heck?!
First – amazing find. But how in the world did I miss it in the morning? I absolutely would have paid full price for all of it.
Second – why was it still there? Probably because the tote was on the floor instead of on a table so everyone just looked right over it, as I must have done that morning.
Half price made the Creative Memories items just 50¢ each!
As I type I still have three Creative Memories lots left from the rummage sale purchase available for sale. Read on to see what has already sold (listed in the order it sold).
Creative Memories 12×12
Natural Pages, Sheet Protectors
Paid: $1, Sold: $29.95
(1 day after listed)
Creative Memories 12×12
White Pages, Sheet Protectors
Paid: $1, Sold: $29.95
(1 day after listed)
Creative Memories 8.5×11
5 White Scrapbook Pages
Paid: $2.50, Sold: $59.95
(2 days after listed)
Creative Memories 7×7
5 Page Protectors
Paid: $2.50, Sold: $59.95
(1 day after listed)
Creative Memories 8.5×11
Scrapbook Pages/Protectors
Paid: $1.50, Sold: $49.95
(2 days after listed)
Creative Memories 7×7 Lot
Albums, Pages, Protectors
Paid: $3.00, Sold: $59.95
(5 days after listed)
Creative Memories 8×8
3 White Scrapbook Pages
Paid: $1.50, Sold: $44.95
(4 days after listed)
Creative Memories 12×12
2 Page Protectors
Paid: $1.00, Sold: $29.95
(6 days after listed)
Creative Memories 12×12
Gold Dust Pages + Protectors
Paid: $1.00, Sold: $29.95
(9 days after listed)
Creative Memories 12×12 Lot
Albums, Pages, Protectors
Paid: $3.00, Sold: $99.95
(19 days after listed)
Creative Memories 12×12 Lot
Album, Pages, Protectors
Paid: $1.50, Sold: $59.95
(26 days after listed)
I have grossed over $550 so far. Not bad at all!
Happy hunting!
Shari Harniss says
April 19, 2020 at 5:01 amSo happy to see a post from you! I was hoping all was well.
Lots of people starting or finishing scrapbooks during all this down time, that’s for sure!
I’m glad you found those goodies!
Mandy Zuniga says
April 20, 2020 at 5:36 pmWoohoo!! That’s awesome! I love it when I come across a cheap haul of stuff like this!
Mandy Zuniga recently posted…Seedling Sprouts- We Have Progress!
Melissa says
April 21, 2020 at 8:49 amWow! Great Find! I love finding Creative Memories items to resell. They are becoming harder to find but I have seen a few here and there at Goodwill in the last few years.
Krista says
July 4, 2020 at 12:59 pmAwesome find! Scoring lots is my absolute favourite, it’s like Christmas!
Melissa says
April 11, 2021 at 8:53 amAre you still selling on ebay? I have missed your blog updates. Hope you are your family are doing well.